Print Page | Close Window

prop/problems

Printed From: Bavarian-Board.co.uk - BMW Owners Discussion Forum
Category: Technical & Model Specific Forums
Forum Name: BMW 5 Series
Forum Discription: This forum will deal with any issues on the BMW 5 Series (E12, E28, E34, E39, E60 & E61)
URL: http://www.bavarian-board.co.uk/forum_posts.asp?TID=9636
Printed Date: 05-May-2024 at 02:53


Topic: prop/problems
Posted By: b8alk
Subject: prop/problems
Date Posted: 05-August-2004 at 20:24
hi all   i have had this vibration now for about 8 months i have replaced ever bush on the car ill start again all that has not been replaced is the prop and half shafts the vibration starts at 70mph and has gone at 85mph and is back at 100mph on wards, it feel like it comes from midd of car or poss from rear bmw have had the car twice and can find no fault, a specialist as been over it once recognises there is a prob but does not no what ,my local garage has had the car all day and has now told me he thinks its the roach joint on the prop therefore needing a new propshaft, i have spent 100s and 100s of pounds trying to sort this problem out all to no avail if some body can help me on this i will be very grateful other wise i will have to sale the car....what with the money im throwing at it and the serious grief im getting of the wife to get shot     

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                



Replies:
Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 05-August-2004 at 20:39
Have you ruled out wheel/tyre vibration ? Has your flexdisc coupling been replaced recently ? Normally when the driveshaft is faulty you can feel the vibration through the rear seat ?

I wouldn't be happy selling a car with a known (possibly serious) fault


Miles

-------------

1991 525i Sport Manual

http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 05-August-2004 at 20:49
hi miles yes i have tryed wheels and tyres/brakes/hubs/bearings/so on and so i have just been told by wife that cost so far is£1347.89p you can feel it though all seats. Im not happy selling my car full stop..... but what else can i do but run it in for a part x

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 05-August-2004 at 20:56
I bet you could source a good second hand prop for a reasonable sum ?


Miles

-------------

1991 525i Sport Manual

http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 05-August-2004 at 21:31
im going to try fab

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 08-August-2004 at 08:49
Car has new prop being fitted wednesday,, i do so hope this sorts it.. 

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 16-August-2004 at 20:13
have just picked up car from workshop they have fitted new complete prop and have told me every thing on my car is spot on there is nothing at fault SO WHY HAVE I STILL GOT THIS ******* VIBRATION

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 16-August-2004 at 21:32
Sorry to hear that....Are you sure it isn't the wheels causing the problem ?



Miles

-------------

1991 525i Sport Manual

http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">


Posted By: W@zzA
Date Posted: 17-August-2004 at 00:19

I had a similar thing after fitting s/h wheels (17"x8" style 36 I think) a few weeks ago although they were the same style as my old wheels, they had a 98 stamp (obviously not E34) and 74mm spigot bores my old wheels had a 93 stamp and 72.5mm spigot bores.  I machined some spacer rings tonight for the front and it cured the problem I didn't have to do the rears as I recently found a pair of brand new 9" rears stamped 93.

Warren

p.s. you must remove the wheel and mesure the bore from the back where fits the hub spigot!



-------------
1995 E34 525 Sport in Daytona Violet


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 17-August-2004 at 20:36
hi, no the wheels have been on the car for the last 11 years,and they do not have spigots,but thanks anyway, i have tried different wheels/tyres just in case wife had hit kerb? at some time but made no odds, i really do not know what to try next. the only thing i have not replaced is o/s/r hub??? and i mean i have replaced every suspension/steering component inc all brakes and now the prop...

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: BOYBIMMERM3
Date Posted: 17-August-2004 at 20:40

have you tried gearbox or engine mounts?



Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 17-August-2004 at 20:55

no there is no movement from either it feels to me like it is coming from the rear but you can feel it in the base of the seat and you can watch the head restraints vibrate not mad though.

(sorry you had to edit guys)



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 18-August-2004 at 10:59
I know its not the cheapest place to take your car but has a main dealer ever investigated the problem for you ?

Oooops just read your original post again and you say that it has been to a BMW dealer twice, i wonder if there are any other main dealers local to you ?


Miles

-------------

1991 525i Sport Manual

http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 21-August-2004 at 11:59

hi yes have been to different m/ds both have no idea both suggested the prop thats why i had a new one fitted car now going in to have the drivers side rear hub looked ,at does anyone know what a hub kit consists off? or what part of the hub could cause this problem?i have no audable noises just this vibration

thanks again Miles for your view do you know what the numbers relate to on your 1st diagram?as this well help me in knowing what parts to order.



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 30-August-2004 at 03:08

Andy

Was reading a technical book at the weekend and I think I may have some different causes to your prop shaft woes.....which won't be cured by ploping on a new prop shaft.  Seeing as how you have tried everything you have nothing to loose......

One cause of prop shaft vibration is due to the fact that the angles that are made at each universal joint MUST be the same otherwise, Hooke's law comes into effect or out of effect, sorry can't remember which.  For example if the angle at the gearbox end is 5 deg then the angle at the diff must be also 5 deg.  If there is a variaion in the angles then the rotational speed of parts of the universal joint will be different. 

As the joint rotates the spider moves on its axis, as it moves on its axis it changes the radius of the spider, thus if the radius changes the rotational speed must change and its this change that causes the vibration as there are two different speeds.  BUT this is cancelled out when there are two universal joints in a shaft provided they are both at the SAME angle.  This is why shafts have two universal joints.

Basically check that your diff is mounted correctly in the suspension system and also that the tail end of the gearbox is correctly located on its mount.  Doing this will make sure that you have the right angles for the drive line.

If your diff and gearbox are out of alignment i.e. you can't get matching angles at your prop shaft universals, no new prop shaft will cure it as your are bolting it on to something that is not in the right positions to start with.

Also make sure that the mating faces of the prop shaft joints are perfectly clean with no crap or rust on the faces.  The joints do not rely on the shear capacity of the bolts to transmit the load but the friction grip between the flanges of the joint.  The joint is clamped by the bolts which generate the friction to keep the two flanges together.  If one of your flanges on your gearbox or diff isn't perfectly flat then it won't mate properly with the prop shaft flange which will upset the angle of the joint as described before.

Hope I haven't confused anyone with some complicated physics!

Andrew

 



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 30-August-2004 at 05:08
Thanks for that andrew im having side shafts done at moment but if that does not help i will get these angles checked by bmw along with the mounts, thanks again

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: studyolic
Date Posted: 30-August-2004 at 15:11
This is probably way off beam, but I wondered if you have had a
full 4 - wheel alignment recently? If the car has nudgd a kerb or
gone over a few holes the thrust axis may be out, which a proper 4 -
wheel alignment will fix at no great expense.   Just get a good
mechanic to do the job!      Sorry you're having so much trouble.




-------------
Richard.

Current; 2000 316i Compact 1.9
previous; 1999 535i V8,    
1995 316i Compact 1.6


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 31-August-2004 at 04:46
hi richard i have had bmw do a wheel alignment not sure if its the same as you are talking about but they found it to be spot on?

-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: 520ian
Date Posted: 01-September-2004 at 10:43

Hi,

in all this, have you checked the ride height at the back of the car?

Ian.



-------------
Ian.

White Smooth and Damn Quick!


Posted By: 318is-joe
Date Posted: 02-September-2004 at 09:58

b8alk

Have You checked the differential carrier bushing's????

 



Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 04-September-2004 at 15:21

Thanks to all for your help on this matter,promblem now sorted it was the rear off side sideshaft spline

Car now sold

Again thankyou to all that tried to help



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 04-September-2004 at 15:31
Wow, you sold that quickly, how much did you get for it ? How's the vectra going ?



Miles

-------------

1991 525i Sport Manual

http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 04-September-2004 at 17:26

Yes to a dealer as i want NO come backs,

the vec,s good the plan is to have a couple of year old top spec motor as our family car from now on but not a bm,and go on the hunt for a 635 highline after xmas as my toy.. 



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: W@zzA
Date Posted: 06-September-2004 at 22:45

Was it loose or worn splines? Inner or outer?

Just out of interest.

Warren



-------------
1995 E34 525 Sport in Daytona Violet


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 07-September-2004 at 02:47

Andy

Tell us more about what the problem was so I/we know what to do in the future.

If you fixed it why did you sell it and to a dealer?  Was the Mrs giving you serious brain damage about spending all that cash on the problem?

I had to get rid of my last car (to a dealer) cos I couldn't get rid of a hesitation problem and my Mrs was giving me brain damage about spending cash on it trying to fix it.

 

If you are into big vast fast Vauxhalls, why not try and hunt down one of the last Senator 3.0i 24v monsters - 204bhp on tap!

Andrew

 



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 07-September-2004 at 14:24
Originally posted by W@zzA W@zzA wrote:

Was it loose or worn splines? Inner or outer?

Just out of interest.

Warren

outer. the spline shaft was bent but not enough to see the wheel wobble on a ramp but enough to wear the front edge of the spline got a replacement from breakers as i had spent far to much money on it at this point.



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 07-September-2004 at 14:42
Originally posted by Andrew Rolland Andrew Rolland wrote:

Andy

Tell us more about what the problem was so I/we know what to do in the future.

If you fixed it why did you sell it and to a dealer?  Was the Mrs giving you serious brain damage about spending all that cash on the problem?

I had to get rid of my last car (to a dealer) cos I couldn't get rid of a hesitation problem and my Mrs was giving me brain damage about spending cash on it trying to fix it.

 

If you are into big vast fast Vauxhalls, why not try and hunt down one of the last Senator 3.0i 24v monsters - 204bhp on tap!

Andrew

 

question one as above answered.

                   "        two sold it to a dealer as i not longer had any faith in the car and i did not wont to give some poor bloke/lass a money pit ,at least if they buy it from a dealer they will have some come back if the car continues down the same path ie problems.

question three as for being into fast vauxhalls NO NO NO NO NO NO NO AND ESPECIALLY NOT OLD ONES.............. my vec is only 2 years old low miles and top spec and makes an ideal family car and thats it..202 bhp is only 9 more than my vec anyway according to the hand book, and it don,t weigh no were near as much. Dont forget the latter v6 vecs are quad cams and there no slouch, not that i want to get into that it was brought as a family car,  my 636 h/l will be my next toy



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 08-September-2004 at 03:00

Andy

I have to admire your honesty by using a car dealer to get shot of a car you had lost faith in.  I guess you didn't want someone breaking down your door two weeks after you sold it thru the Autotrader! 

I did that, lost all faith in my last car (3.0i 24v Senator) so took the £300 p/x against my Beamer offered by the dealer, instead of getting £500 by selling privately cos I quite like my front door you see.

 

Andrew



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 08-September-2004 at 14:47
Originally posted by Andrew Rolland Andrew Rolland wrote:

Andy

I have to admire your honesty by using a car dealer to get shot of a car you had lost faith in.  I guess you didn't want someone breaking down your door two weeks after you sold it thru the Autotrader! 

I did that, lost all faith in my last car (3.0i 24v Senator) so took the £300 p/x against my Beamer offered by the dealer, instead of getting £500 by selling privately cos I quite like my front door you see.

Having somebody at my door was not the problem. The problem was more having to lie to that person and tell them what a great car it was, when all it had been in the last 8-9 months was a money pit.Icould not do that to anyone,im just not that kind of person.

 

Andrew



-------------
E34 M30 535i SPORT



                                



Print Page | Close Window