Print Page | Close Window

Rolling Road Day - Report and Pics

Printed From: Bavarian-Board.co.uk - BMW Owners Discussion Forum
Category: Regional & Specific Forums
Forum Name: Scottish Forum
Forum Discription: where Scottish regional members can discuss upcoming events
URL: http://www.bavarian-board.co.uk/forum_posts.asp?TID=44267
Printed Date: 29-April-2024 at 21:44


Topic: Rolling Road Day - Report and Pics
Posted By: nero
Subject: Rolling Road Day - Report and Pics
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 17:56
Today saw our much requested Rolling Road Day at Hypertech, Bonnybridge.
Despite a few late dropouts, we still had 9 cars up on the rollers.

There was a mixed bag of results, which I'll let the individuals concerned discuss.
Main problems seem to be with the M cars with limiters cutting in too early.
What did seem to work on Cliff's M3 was to take it for a run, then put it straight onto the rollers without stopping the engine.

Apart from that another good day and nice to see everyone again


Onno


Andrew R


Curnrik



Webdunk


Rab


Stevie



Jim


Cliff


Fluffnik


-------------








Replies:
Posted By: Webdunk
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:17
Good snaps Neil - thanks!

Mixed feelings about the day :

- Really pleased with the number of folk who popped in to say hello over and above those taking part. I think this was one of our busier meets of the year so far.

- Very happy with the welcome from Hypertech and their approachable, friendly nature.

- Not so happy with the issues getting realistic numbers from a good few of the cars. Onno's and Curnriks were very believable with figures very much in the region of manufacturer's claims. The E39 M5s hated the rollers as usual which I found disappointing having broached the issues ahead of the day. Andrew's E60 didn't fancy staying in gear to get a clear run which again had been discussed beforehand.

- My own car did not even get close to where it should be; coming up with 239.8@6125 revs on the plot. This despite the fact that the car was revving clean and true to just north of 7000revs as indicated by the rev counter so I suspect there was some issue at play here - especially as the 3.2 Evo which followed me on to the rollers exhibited the same issue and made i.r.o. 30bhp more than the GT which is close to what you would have expected based on BMW's figures for the cars.

-------------


Posted By: Cambell
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:31

Well guys, I enjoyed my wee visit as did my big Brother Vic.

I am absolutely gutted about not getting my car on the rollers but as a few of you know, my exhaust seems to have given up the ghost so I recon that if I'd put it on, the exhaust would have probably gone bang (completely) and I wouldn't get a true reading anyway.

A huge thanks to all who organised this event, I know that it was done partially on my request (along with others) like I said, gutted I didn't get on the rollers.



-------------


Posted By: Pete330
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:34

Great pics

Dunc your car looks mean on the rollers,colour coded cables

Shame about the read outs,but hey ho it was a good day out?

 

Fluffs car just fits lol



-------------
Previous:

E36 318is coupe, E36 323i coupe, E30 316 saloon, E30 318 saloon, E46 330ci Sport Conv
E92 325d M Sport(3.0),With Loads of gadgets

Current:
116i Sport F20


Posted By: jimmy136
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:40
hi everybody, enjoyed this today and meeting some new faces,  this being only my second meet, hope to make some more this year by the way the sound out of that m5 o' stevie's on them rollers today was phenomenal

-------------


Posted By: vpricey
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:43
Definately a good day oot, but there was some funny things going on with the Rolling Road I'd say, but hay ho, I only got a couple of pics and a Video of Stevie's runs, the runs start around 2minutes into the video so skip a bit



http://s61.photobucket.com/albums/h79/vpricey/?action=view&current=MOV04175.flv">




-------------
Paul - '87 E30 325i Sport - '99 E39 M5 - '05 E53 X5


Posted By: nero
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 18:53
Originally posted by vpricey vpricey wrote:

... I only got a couple of pics and a Video of Stevie's runs, the runs start around 2minutes into the video so skip a bit


Houston - we have lift off

That sound is awesome ...


-------------







Posted By: Issy
Date Posted: 15-March-2009 at 21:40

We had a great day today lots of banter and cold feet!!  

Well done to Duncan &  Ono for getting this off the ground. Thanks to Hypertech for keeping us supplied with tea/coffee & biscuits.

Some we videos from me .....

http://s178.photobucket.com/albums/w253/issyco/?action=view&current=RRday15thmarch09009.flv - Stevie  

http://s178.photobucket.com/albums/w253/issyco/?action=view&current=RRday15thmarch09013.flv - Stevie2

http://s178.photobucket.com/albums/w253/issyco/?action=view&current=RRday15thmarch09018.flv - Cliff  

http://s178.photobucket.com/albums/w253/issyco/?action=view&current=RRday15thmarch09021.flv - Cliff2



-------------




Posted By: fluffnik
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 00:57
Originally posted by Pete330 Pete330 wrote:

Fluffs car just fits lol



Ludolph the Legnum has a Very (big) Shiny Nose... 

I got sensible(ish) numbers and the car and rollers played nicely together - my gearbox neither upshifts nor kicksdown in tip mode - once they'd shrunk the road to suit my wheelbase.

A chilly but fun day, if a little frustrating for the ///M folks.




-------------
ALPINA B10 V8 Touring #36


Posted By: stevie53
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 06:47
enjoyed some of my day, Had a laugh catching up with you all pity I can't say the same about the later part of the day.

the rollers issue was exactly what I expected, what I didn't expect was for my gearlinkage to collapse and leave me stuck in 4th gear for the majority of the trip home
waiting for the ambulance now to take it back to the A&E



-------------
///2000 E39 M5 Imola Red/// NO MORE

una volta lei ha avuto l'italiano lei non andrą mai tedesco di nuovo haha


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 08:24

Just wanted to say thanks to Ono and Duncan for doing the organising.  And thanks to Neil for the photos.  I enjoyed meeting a few new faces, Jim and Alistair.

I was a bit disappointed with my result 286 bhp which I was told was due to the autobox wanting to change.  But I reckon it was worth doing for the experience and just to say I've done it. 

I'm really not sure how it could have been run any other way.  The car needs to be told to stay in gear, mibbie plugging in a laptop to override the ECU???

My dad really enjoyed it esp seeing a number of M3 and M5 models in the flesh.  Thanks to Stevie and Jim for letting me and the old boy look over a couple of nice Ms! Sorry to hear about your tale of woe Stevie, hope you get it sorted.

Andrew

PS Guys, I would strongly recommend that you check your rear tyre pressures as the wee lad was supposedly putting them up to 45 psi and then re-setting them back to normal, but mine weren't even anywhere near right when I checked them before going home!  And the wee lad lost one of my dust caps and tried to tell me there wasn't even one on that side!



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: sailorbaz
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 09:14
Good wee morning spend with automotive porn. Judging on
Cliffs figures of about 290, and mine of 311 those
rollers seem to reading about 50 down.

Was good being able to just nip along for a wee butchers
as you said Duncan. There was a good number that come
along for a look and meet.

Bumper going on this morning, can't wait to get mine out
after being out in Colin's yesterday afternoon,


-------------


http://www.bmwccscotland.co.uk/cars/e46/m3csl.html" rel="nofollow - My Car

2004 M3 CSL and 2009 E90 M3


Posted By: Webdunk
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 09:24
Originally posted by sailorbaz sailorbaz wrote:

Judging on Cliffs figures of about 290, and mine of 311 those rollers seem to reading about 50 down.


Yup that matches mine and the Evo. But why so consistently down I wonder? I see your RPM at peak power at least looks believable...

-------------


Posted By: Crombers
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 16:37

Originally posted by stevie53 stevie53 wrote:

enjoyed some of my day, Had a laugh catching up with you all pity I can't say the same about the later part of the day.

the rollers issue was exactly what I expected, what I didn't expect was for my gearlinkage to collapse and leave me stuck in 4th gear for the majority of the trip home
waiting for the ambulance now to take it back to the A&E

 

Gutted to have missed the day, and sorry to hear of your breakdown.  Be sure to say hi to my motor should you be down B4BMW anytime soon Stevie!

I'm starting to forget that I actually own a car having seen so little of it this year for one reason or another!

 

 



-------------



Alpina B7 E65 Facelift
Alpina B10 V8 Touring (Sold)


Posted By: M3 Cliff
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 16:44

  Yeah im not bothered one bit to all the figures of the M's are roughlly or dead on 50 brake down so figure that out ?, But to be excactlly twenty behind barry tells you both our cars are running perfect in my mind. i put money on it that these cars would make the power on another set of rollers.

A big thanks to izzy for driving me through and putting up with me and another thanks to mark for the advice on getting the car to rev round to the limit,    



-------------
[IMG]http://bavarian-board.co.uk/uploads/Webdunk/cliffsig.jpg">


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 17:13

Just another thought about the figures for my car.

Book figures for mine are 333 bhp and 450 Nm of torque.

According to the print out I got, my bhp was 286 and the torque was just shy of 450 which I took as being o.k. as that was what the book figure was.  On a closer look at the graph my car according to the rollers produced 450 lbft torque which is not the same as 450 Nm of torque.  450 lbft torque = 610Nm!!!!

If I had 610 Nm of torque going thru my gearbox I would be a bit worried as it has a torque design limit of 600 Nm.

So it would appear the the rollers under estimated bhp by about 50 bhp (286 + 50 = 336bhp which would be over the book values for me, just) but the torque was over estimated by about 1/3 which is quite something.

Can the rest of you guys look at your torque figures and let me know your thoughts.

Andrew



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: curnrik
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 18:46

It was a good day, good seeing new faces, and some nice cars turned up.

I was pleased with my results:-  173.8, book on her is 170. So i was well chuffed.

But i wasn't so chuffed with the battery in my camera, i was hoping to get a lot more video. An in car charger and a second battery ordered from amazon today.

I'm going to try and get some blank CD's and copy every thing i took. I'm planning on brining them to Davey's if anyone wants one.

 



-------------
http://www.richardcurran.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/bmws/cunrik1024x768.jpg - My E36 323 pic1



Posted By: stevie53
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 20:36
Originally posted by Crombers Crombers wrote:

Originally posted by stevie53 stevie53 wrote:

enjoyed some of my day, Had a laugh catching up with you all pity I can't say the same about the later part of the day. the rollers issue was exactly what I expected, what I didn't expect was for my gearlinkage to collapse and leave me stuck in 4th gear for the majority of the trip home waiting for the ambulance now to take it back to the A&E


 


Gutted to have missed the day, and sorry to hear of your breakdown.  Be sure to say hi to my motor should you be down B4BMW anytime soon Stevie!


I'm starting to forget that I actually own a car having seen so little of it this year for one reason or another!


 


 

Crombers, I dropped my car off this morning and never noticed it. I was only in the Audi side & never got a chance to speak to Keith. looks like mine is going to be in there for the best part of the week, waiting on back order part from Germany. I'll be sure to look out for it when I'm back down



-------------
///2000 E39 M5 Imola Red/// NO MORE

una volta lei ha avuto l'italiano lei non andrą mai tedesco di nuovo haha


Posted By: vpricey
Date Posted: 16-March-2009 at 21:05
Just had a wee search on tinter web, and the guy should have been doing the dyno runs in 5th on both the e36 and e46 M3's and the M5s, as this is the 1:1 ratio in the gear box, so I'm not sue if this would cause the difference but I might imagine so

Oh and what did Fluffy's Jap beast put out??lol.




-------------
Paul - '87 E30 325i Sport - '99 E39 M5 - '05 E53 X5


Posted By: fluffnik
Date Posted: 17-March-2009 at 02:19
Originally posted by vpricey vpricey wrote:


Oh and what did Fluffy's Jap beast put out??lol.


218.3 @ ~5750rpm

The lower end of the torqueue curve makes no sense though...

>320ftlb @ ~1200rpm

I should bleedin' co-co John!

The 220 - 200 ftlb plateau between 3k and 5.5k corelates well with the turbos expected behaviour but overall there's summut weird in the torque/power relationship as plotted.

Bottom line:

The car overtook as desired 4-up in the borders today; the B10 would have been quicker everywhere...

The AFR plot which I saw but don't have a print of suggests that taking boost to the 0.8 bar used by manual VR4s should not be a problem, especially with the additional transmission cooling we're fitting.

Hey! It's the shopping car. 

The Legnum is a phenomenal bit of kit, though it does feel down to a price compared to the E39 - there's slight shuttle shake on M-way ridges and the fittings are functional but plasticy - and will undoubtedly make a better Alpine load lugger than the late E220.


-------------
ALPINA B10 V8 Touring #36


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 17-March-2009 at 08:01

Originally posted by fluffnik fluffnik wrote:


The lower end of the torqueue curve makes no sense though...

>320ftlb @ ~1200rpm

Yeah there is something very wrong with the torque results from this Rolling Road.  I think his torque calibration must be way out as my car was putting out more torque than the gearbox can handle safely!



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: Webdunk
Date Posted: 17-March-2009 at 09:33


Looks like :

232lb/ft @ 4125rpm (314.5NM so right torque at wrong rpm?)
239.8bhp @ 6125rpm

vs run on Maha :

310.8NM @ 5235rpm
292.4bhp @ 7360rpm

-------------


Posted By: broos3
Date Posted: 18-March-2009 at 21:13
I enjoyed the RR day on sunday. Bar the fact the rolling road /operator was poor. (just my 2p worth)

Was good meeting up with you guys again and met afew more of you. As I said Andrew realy like the 545i, its a real sleeper and in great condition!! Hope you get the wee bits of tyre of the rear 1/4 panels.

Also good speaking to Rab with the other M3 evo. Good to comapre faults etc.

Craig


-------------
E36 M3 evo Saloon
E36 325i Track Car
Sierra RS Cosworth


Posted By: rabj
Date Posted: 20-March-2009 at 13:09

Thanks to Duncan and everyone who organised the day.

Was good to get my car on the rollers and get a base figure to work on.  The figure I got was slightly disappointing until you look at the other figures produced.

Anyone will tell you that most M3 Evo's will not produce the advertised 321 PS (316bhp) so if you take the 50bhp "missing" from the M3 GT, E46 M3 and CSL, I should be looking at an actual 321bhp which is a fantsatic output for a midly tuned Evo (Simota CAI, superchip). I will be putting it on another dyno (probably Star) to find out. 

Here's my graph

 

 



-------------


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 20-March-2009 at 13:35

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:

As I said Andrew realy like the 545i, its a real sleeper and in great condition!! Hope you get the wee bits of tyre of the rear 1/4 panels.

Cheers Craig.  Have you got any more piccies of the Cosworth?  Ditch the BMW and get the Cozzie going.

What's more annoying is that I had made a right hash of removing the sealant I had put on the rear wings etc the day before, now that the car is a bit dirty you can see where I hadn't buffed off the sealant.  It sets rock hard and is a real pain to shift.

That reminds me I need to get more BMW dust caps as one went missing after my tyre pressures "were adjusted" by the RR staff.

Andrew



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: fluffnik
Date Posted: 20-March-2009 at 16:26
"Torque converter flare" does not seem sufficient explanation for the lower end of this:



-------------
ALPINA B10 V8 Touring #36


Posted By: broos3
Date Posted: 20-March-2009 at 21:04





There are some pictures of the Sierra for you Andrew and others who are interested. I might get some better pics of it put together later and put a proper post up. The pics are abit old and the sh*te strut brace has been removed and the car is back to completly original.

The car its just a summer car and hardly gets used. Sits in the garage all the time and gets cleaned more than it gets driven as you can see haha.

Craig


-------------
E36 M3 evo Saloon
E36 325i Track Car
Sierra RS Cosworth


Posted By: curnrik
Date Posted: 22-March-2009 at 01:06

Oh yeah she looks the part, RS cossie or XR4x4, i wanted one of those. But if i could have any Ford right now, i'd Take the Capri any day. My childhood dream car. 2.8 injection in black oh yes.

 



-------------
http://www.richardcurran.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/bmws/cunrik1024x768.jpg - My E36 323 pic1



Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 22-March-2009 at 15:01

Nice Cozzie

I'd have a V6 2.3 Ghia Cortina.

Wonder what it would produce on a rolling road.  120 bhp mibbie?  At least it would have worked properly and not cut out due to fancy electronics in the engine.



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: stephenperry
Date Posted: 22-March-2009 at 16:28

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:






There are some pictures of the Sierra for you Andrew and others who are interested. I might get some better pics of it put together later and put a proper post up. The pics are abit old and the sh*te strut brace has been removed and the car is back to completly original.

The car its just a summer car and hardly gets used. Sits in the garage all the time and gets cleaned more than it gets driven as you can see haha.

Craig

Good to see another sierra owner (i have an original 1983 XR4i), they're getting thin on the ground these days 



Posted By: broos3
Date Posted: 22-March-2009 at 18:46
Originally posted by stephenperry stephenperry wrote:

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:






There are some pictures of the Sierra for you Andrew and others who are interested. I might get some better pics of it put together later and put a proper post up. The pics are abit old and the sh*te strut brace has been removed and the car is back to completly original.

The car its just a summer car and hardly gets used. Sits in the garage all the time and gets cleaned more than it gets driven as you can see haha.

Craig

Good to see another sierra owner (i have an original 1983 XR4i), they're getting thin on the ground these days 



Yeh they are getting thin on the ground. I Still realy enjoying driving the cosworth, its razzer sharpe and the gearshift from the T5 is amazing.

I realy like the XR4i's, red with the grey bumpers looked great. Get some pics up of the old girl.


-------------
E36 M3 evo Saloon
E36 325i Track Car
Sierra RS Cosworth


Posted By: stephenperry
Date Posted: 22-March-2009 at 21:01

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:

I realy like the XR4i's, red with the grey bumpers looked great. Get some pics up of the old girl.

My dad has owned it for 20 years (so far!) of its 26 year life, 86,000 miles from new and all original including paint and bodywork (apart from the cosworth steering wheel which i bought brand new as a birthday present but the original two-spoke wheel with twin-button horn push is in storage)



Posted By: jimmy136
Date Posted: 23-March-2009 at 17:44

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:

I realy like the XR4i's, red with the grey bumpers looked great. Get some pics up of the old girl.

that brings back some happy memories, i used to have one o them

dear knows where it is now though, them pics are about 20 years old



-------------


Posted By: stephenperry
Date Posted: 23-March-2009 at 18:23
Originally posted by jimmy136 jimmy136 wrote:

dear knows where it is now though, them pics are about 20 years old


The enquiry is complete
The vehicle details for A87 WOS are:

Date of Liability 01 02 1997
Date of First Registration 01 08 1983
Year of Manufacture 1983
Cylinder Capacity (cc) 2792CC
CO2 Emissions Not Available
Fuel Type Petrol
Export Marker Not Applicable
Vehicle Status Unlicensed
Vehicle Colour RED
Vehicle Type Approval null

looks like it was scrapped or SORNed in 1997

http://www.taxdisc.direct.gov.uk/EvlPortalApp/application?origin=vnav_bar.jsp&event=bea.portal.framework.internal.refresh&pageid=Vehicle+Enquiry - http://www.taxdisc.direct.gov.uk/EvlPortalApp/application?or igin=vnav_bar.jsp&event=bea.portal.framework.internal.re fresh&pageid=Vehicle+Enquiry



Posted By: broos3
Date Posted: 23-March-2009 at 18:24
Two nice xr4i's there. They both have the door edge reflector things haha.

Your car sounds good stephen, good to know a cars past. Was your dad the original owner? Good idea fitting the cosworth wheel in my opinion its a realy nice wheel to drive with.

My cosworth has just ticked over 51k and been garaged most of its life apart from the first 2/3 years.

Craig


-------------
E36 M3 evo Saloon
E36 325i Track Car
Sierra RS Cosworth


Posted By: stephenperry
Date Posted: 23-March-2009 at 18:33

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:


My cosworth has just ticked over 51k and been garaged most of its life apart from the first 2/3 years.

it's a beautiful beast Craig, cossies will always have a special place in my affections, if i could afford a really pristine unmodified 3-door or RS500 i'd buy it in a heartbeat

Originally posted by broos3 broos3 wrote:

Was your dad the original owner? Good idea fitting the cosworth wheel in my opinion its a realy nice wheel to drive with.

No, he bought it in 1989 when it was six years old.  A mate of his at the time had a white one and when he had a drive he was smitten and thus started the hunt for one.  It was a daily driver up until he stored it in 1993 so I could learn to drive (never afford the insurance on it at the time and he was niggly about an inexperienced 17-year old behind the wheel, no idea why )  Since then it comes out of the garage during the summer months maybe once every few years?  It doesn't get used like it probably should but he loves the car so much I don't think he'll never sell it, we've got filing cabinets full of period promotional material, magazine reviews, XR4i model cars, the garage is stacked with spare parts "just in case", it's mental!  Got to have a hobby I suppose.... I keep on at him about taking it to car shows but that's not his thing, he likes going to shows to see other cars but not interested in showing it, shame really



Posted By: davy tombstone
Date Posted: 23-March-2009 at 19:58
sorry ford nuts but getting back on topic.
was browsing another forum today and a post caught my eye to do with RR an m3
quote:hold dsc button in for more than 20 secs, dsc sign goes off and cannot be turned back on unless car is restarted, car goes into service mode, can be dyno,d up to red line and all electronic systems are off.
just wodered if this could be a contributing facor.

-------------
http://s324.photobucket.com/user/davytombstone/media/newsig_zpsd6056b1d.jpg.html" rel="nofollow">


Posted By: broos3
Date Posted: 24-March-2009 at 19:31
Yeh davy, That could well be the key. I cant beleive I did not remember this on the day. Its a good tip when you want to switch the TC off!! 




-------------
E36 M3 evo Saloon
E36 325i Track Car
Sierra RS Cosworth


Posted By: Andrew Rolland
Date Posted: 25-March-2009 at 08:38

My traction control (DSC/DTC ABC DEF etc etc) was well and trully off on the RR and the car performed well untill the input revs got to much for the gearbox and it changed up, spoiling the power run.

My car was taken to the red line about a split second before the gearbox decided to change up, boo.  Was good fun though.

Andrew



-------------
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto


Posted By: nero
Date Posted: 28-March-2009 at 12:07
I've now added a page to the BMWCCScotland website, with more pictures

http://www.bmwccscotland.co.uk/meets/2009/march/hypertech.php - http://www.bmwccscotland.co.uk/meets/2009/march/hypertech.ph p


-------------








Print Page | Close Window