The good: Among the 2008 BMW M3 Convertible
driving tech is electronic damping control, double-clutch transmission,
and a four-liter V-8 producing 414 horsepower. Impressive cabin tech is
available including a navigation system with live traffic.
The bad:
Fuel economy is not great, although the double-clutch transmission
helps a bit, and the car commands a hefty price. When the top is
lowered, trunk space is minimal.
The bottom line:
The 2008 BMW M3 Convertible delivers an exceptional driving experience.
The M3's double-clutch transmission and cabin tech are first rate, but
options quickly jack up the base price.
CNET editors' review
- Reviewed by:
Wayne Cunningham
- Reviewed on:
09/11/2008
We reviewed the BMW M3 Coupe
with a manual transmission and the full load of cabin tech back in
April, but we couldn't pass up the opportunity to test out another one,
this time the 2008 BMW M3 Convertible with the new double-clutch
transmission. Although our convertible M3 lacked the cabin tech
options, not even having the programmable M button on the steering
wheel, it still proved a remarkable car to drive with all the
performance capabilities of the loaded version. And we didn't think it
possible to improve on the M3's performance, but the double-clutch
transmission makes the car even more exciting to drive.
Test the tech: DCT versus MPG When we took a brief drive in
a DCT equipped M3 earlier this year, we noted that the trip computer
was reporting more than 17 mpg fuel economy. While that number doesn't
sound impressive, it is a notable improvement over the 15 mpg we saw
from the manual transmission BMW M3 Coupe we tested earlier.
Speculating that the increased fuel economy was because of the
double-clutch transmission, we paid special attention to this number
for our full test of the BMW M3 Convertible.
The double-clutch transmission uses a different shifter than the base six-speed manual transmission.
The DCT is a manual transmission with two gear shafts, each with its
own computer-controlled clutch. When driving, one clutch will engage a
gear on its shaft, while the other clutch sits ready to engage the next
up or down gear, with the computer determining the most likely next
gear you will want. In manual mode, you can choose to shift up or down
using steering wheel paddles or the shifter. Because the computer
controls the clutches, there is no clutch pedal. The car also has an
automatic mode, where the computer determines when to shift up or down.
The BMW M3 Coupe we tested had a standard six-speed manual. The
double-clutch transmission has seven gears.
However, the DCT isn't the only difference between these two
cars. The BMW M3 Coupe gets a carbon fiber roof, while the BMW M3
Convertible uses a retractable hardtop, which means an extra 441 pounds
of curb weight for the convertible. That weight difference should give
the M3 Coupe an advantage in fuel economy.
According to the EPA, the BMW M3 Convertible with the
double-clutch transmission should get 16 mpg city and 20 mpg highway.
The M3 Coupe with the manual transmission is rated at 14 mpg city and
20 mpg highway. In our testing in dense urban traffic, twisty mountain
roads, and 65 mph freeways, we saw an average of 16.2 mpg for the M3
Convertible with the double-clutch transmission. In our earlier test,
the BMW M3 Coupe with the manual transmission got 15 mpg. So the DCT
clearly offers an advantage even when laden with an extra 441 pounds.
For a little more comparison, we saw 16.2 mpg with the seven speed
automatic-equipped Mercedes-Benz C63 AMG, and 14 mpg with the dual clutch manual-equipped Nissan GT-R.
Driving
along at 45 mph, the double-clutch transmission's automatic mode puts
the car into seventh gear, which keeps the tach to less than 2,000rpm.
Why does the double-clutch transmission do better in fuel economy than
a manual transmission? When we had the M3 Convertible in boring driving
conditions, such as in traffic or in the city, we let the computer
handle the shifting. We noticed that the program tended to upshift
earlier than we would have, for example running all the way up to
seventh gear at 45 mph, keeping the tachometer about 1,500rpm. In the
manual M3 Coupe, we would most likely have left it in third gear at 45
mph.
In the cabin Our 2008 BMW M3 Convertible lacked a lot of
the cabin tech we're used to seeing from BMW. Without the navigation
option, there is no LCD on the instrument panel. Instead, you get a
standard stack with the stereo and climate controls. Take a look at our
review of the BMW M3 Coupe to see what a fully loaded cabin looks like. Standard features include power adjustable leather seats.
The stereo interface, although restricted to a two-line display, lets you scroll through folders on an MP3 CD.
The base stereo is pretty limited for audio sources, having AM and FM
radio, an auxiliary jack in the console, and a single disc slot that
can read MP3 CDs. But even though the radio display only has two lines,
BMW manages a pretty good interface for MP3 CDs. You can scroll through
lists of folders and songs on the disc, and see songs by their ID3 tag.
As in other BMWs we've tested, we noted that the audio system in the M3
Convertible is powerful and delivers good quality sound, but it is far
from the best we've heard. Its highs lack clarity, although the
midrange comes through with strength. Its bass isn't thumping, but it
is solid. This base audio system uses eight speakers. You can get a
premium audio system for the M3 Convertible that uses 12 speakers and
an 825-watt amp.
We had Bluetooth cell phone integration in our car, which comes
with the BMW Assist telematics feature. Even restricted to a two-line
radio display, BMW does an excellent job with cell phone integration.
We paired up our phone, and very quickly could access our phone's
contact list using the stereo controls.
The Bluetooth cell phone system is impressive, even without a large LCD.
The retractable hardtop is also a nice feature, despite the extra
weight. Weekend track drivers will want to opt for the carbon-fiber
roofed Coupe to reduce weight, but the M3 Convertible works as a more
multipurpose car, allowing open-top driving in good weather. We found
the top was a little slow in moving up and down, and it seriously
compromises trunk room, but having it down lets you hear the engine
much better than you can with it up. The sound of the engine changing
speeds with gearshifts was particularly enjoyable.
Under the hood With the BMW M3 Coupe, we reveled in its
power and handling, sticking to third gear, with its wide power band,
as we slung the car around corners, feeling the rear come out just
enough so that the front was pointed in the right direction. Although a
convertible top compromises performance, BMW engineers kept it to a
minimum in the M3 Convertible. We did most of our hard driving with the
top up, to keep the weight balanced properly, and found little
difference between the two cars on public roads.
BMW designs its engines for individual throttle control on each cylinder, allowing for minute performance adjustments.
We took the car on the same route we drove the M3 Coupe, a series of
long, winding roads north of San Francisco, then back down along the
coast on Highway 1. The double-clutch transmission definitely changed
the driving experience--we kept it in manual mode and spent more time
shifting between second gear and third gear than we did with the manual
transmission M3 Coupe, which was content to run in third gear for all
but the tightest turns. Shifting with the DCT is effortless, merely
requiring a pull on the left paddle for downshift and the right for an
upshift.
As an M car, the M3 Convertible has a power button on the console. The
car moves forward sluggishly with it off, requiring you to practically
floor the gas pedal. Given this behavior, we're not sure if leaving it
off improves fuel economy. Leave it on, though, and the throttle
response sharpens considerably, giving the feeling that you've suddenly
gained 50 horsepower. The four-liter V-8 engine is a remarkable piece
of engineering, using BMW's Double-VANOS
for valve control, with individual throttle control for each cylinder.
The result is 414 horsepower at 8,300rpm and 295 foot-pounds of torque
at 3,900rpm.
With the Power and EDC lights all on, the car is ready for the track.
Our car also had the optional electronic damping control, which gives
the suspension three modes, comfort, normal, and sport. EDC should be a
standard feature on the M3, as it seems like a crucial bit of tech to
improve the car's handling. Comfort loosens the suspension up a little,
giving a slightly softer ride. We relied on normal mode for much of our
driving, as it automatically adjusts the suspension damping to your
current driving style. We could feel the difference in handling when we
went from diving into corners to cruising down the highway. One option
our car didn't come with was the programmable M button, which lets you
set the car for sport driving with a single button touch.
BMW incorporates even more programmable technology into the
double-clutch transmission with its DriveLogic settings. A rocker
switch on the console lets you change the gearshift response through
five settings, shown as one to five bars on the instrument cluster
display. You can have different settings for automatic and manual
gearshifts mode, and the car will save them, reverting to the proper
setting when you put the car in manual mode, for example. At one bar,
the shifts feel softer, as the car kicks in a limited amount of torque
during the gearshift. With DriveLogic maximized at five bars, the
shifts feel harder, as the engine adds the maximum amount of torque the
program allows during the gearshift. The difference from one bar to
five is a soft push versus a hard punch in the back during gearshifts.
We kept it at five bars for manual mode, enjoying the visceral feeling
of shifts from second to third, enhanced by amazing engine sounds with
the car's top down.
With five bars for the DriveLogic program, the car adds extra torque during gearshifts.
Driving with the double-clutch transmission, we liked the fact that
we could keep pressure on the gas pedal while shifting. In traffic, the
DCT handled itself well, making smooth shifts at low speeds and
pitching no fuss when it had to sit in first gear at a stop light. BMW
incorporates hill hold tech into the system, too, so that you don't
roll backward during a hill start.
In sum The base price for the 2008 BMW M3 Convertible is a
hefty $66,150, and that's missing much of the tech we've mentioned. Two
features adding significantly to our car were the electronic damping
control, for $1,000, and the double-clutch transmission, for $2,900.
BMW Assist, which brings in telematics and Bluetooth, adds $750. Other
nontech options and an $825 destination fee brought the total up to
$72,925. Cabin tech options we would have chosen for the car would have
been navigation, enhanced audio, and iPod integration, which would have
added $4,400 to the price, putting our convertible sports car close to
$80,000. Getting the convertible adds a pretty serious premium to the
price of a standard M3, but few other companies make convertibles that
perform this well.
The M3 Convertible earns our top rating for performance, with
the superb engine tech, DCT, and EDC all contributing to a sublime
driving experience. Although our test car didn't come with much cabin
tech, we give it credit for the optional navigation and audio systems,
for a strong score in this category. Design is also very good--the car
looks as good as it drives.
|